Wednesday, January 21, 2009

New series: Notes From the Other Side

Considering I just started this blog in October, I would say that there might still be a whiff of that new blog smell around here. As a newcomer to this community I have learned a lot and gotten a good amount of useful feedback from those with more experience in matters of blogging, teaching, being a PI and everything that comes along with that. I appreciate the comments and they have actually changed the way I approach what I post here. My initial intention was to chronicle my experiences with the hope that they would inform those who are now in the position I was a year ago. While I still try and do that, I also now use this forum to draw on the experiences of those who are further along in this process than myself.

With the new semester upon us, I think it's a good time to add another aspect to the blog and that is to talk a bit more about actual science. As I have begun to explore some (I wish I had the time to read further than I do) of the other sciencey blogs out there I've realized that the research programs of bloggers roughly reflects research biases in the US - that is to say that a large sector of the community works in biomed-type fields and of those who do not, many still use model organisms (human, mouse, fruit fly, yeast, Arabidopsis, etc.) in their experiments. Though a lot of people don't reveal their field, I get the impression that nearly all of the bio-bloggers are working on organisms that would be household names (alright, maybe in a geeky house, but still). That puts me in a niche market, I suppose.

Over the next couple of weeks I'm going to try and put a few coherent posts together on some of the interesting things going on outside model organism world. My motivation for doing this actually came from a manuscript I recently reviewed for a high-impact journal. The authors actually wrote the line "We have shown that xx holds true for the entire spectrum of eukaryotic diversity, from humans to yeast". This kind of shit drives me crazy and is the equivalent of saying "Last summer I drove all across the US, from Maine to New Jersey", but I have seen similar statements in a grant and two seminars. I have no idea if the posts in this series will actually attract any readers, but if I can get just one person to realize that eukaryotic diversity hasn't been neatly classified as Animal, Plant or Fungus since the 1950s (or earlier) or that the organisms we can see out our window represent the minority of eukaryotes, then I will be happy. At the very least, it will save my grad students from having to listen to my crazed rants when I come across statements like the one above.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Applicant Hell

Recently I have had to advertise for a PhD student and did so using a few listservs that have fairly substantial followings in the fields I am interested in. My deadline is not until this Friday, but the applicants I have so far are making me very nervous.

I was somewhat specific with what I am looking for. I would prefer someone with an MSc in a related field (even tangentially), some lab experience related to the tasks we are undertaking (which covers a wide range of basic techniques) and some ability to perform, or interest in learning, rudimentary XX. These requirements should not unreasonably narrow the field.

Nevertheless, I have only 7 applicants at this point (still four days prior to the deadline), and only one of these even partially meets my preferred skill set. The majority of the applicants have sent their CVs because I am working in an emerging field and they would like to learn some of the techniques and apply them to their own field of interest. While that is a reasonable goal for them, I am not looking to train a PhD student who is more interested in how they can use our methods to answer questions in their (completely unrelated) system, than they are in working on the project I need people for. It is one thing to have this goal and at least feign interest in the advertised project, but when your letter specifically discusses how you want to learn techniques Y and Z so that you can use them to improve your worm breeding project, then go on to describe the worm breeding project for a page, I'm just not gonna call you up to get you in here.

Granted, I could be worrying for no reason at this stage, with the deadline still ahead. When I applied for positions I never sent in my package substantially before the deadline, so I wouldn't expect others to. But with each new application that comes in from a Pakistani bee-keeper or Romanian goat herder I am becoming increasingly concerned that I may not find anyone suitable. If that is the case, I will essentially lose out on a departmental TAship to support the student and having one more person in the lab who can advance my projects. I don't plan to bring in a seat warmer just to keep the TAship this year, because I know that a bad student in the lab can cripple progress, but it makes me very uncomfortable giving up a lab position at this early point. Therefore, I may be faced with the unappealing options of either taking on a student who I will have to train from scratch and hope for the best, or declining the TAship for a year.

What makes the latter option even less palatable is that the process for assigning TAships to labs is one of the major policies being changed in our college-level reorganization. I was hoping to grab one before the changes happen so that my lab would go into the new system with two TAships, which might bolster my future claims on two or more TAships in the future. If I go into the "merge" (everything has taken on a "Survivor-like" flair around here lately) with only one TAship, I may need to battle to get a second in the future and it will likely take me longer to secure a third. Therefore, obtaining the second TAship or not has longer-lasting consequences than just the next year. We need a metric like the PiT Theorem for the cost/benefit of taking on inexperienced students and securing TAships for the future.

Monday, January 19, 2009

Long hair: Not just a lab hazard

When you have a child who is under a year old, you spend more time than you ever thought possible around poop. It's a common topic of conversation and you are constantly cleaning it up or evaluating it's consistency. There is no conscious decision one day to make poop a bigger part of your life than ever before, it just happens when you have a small child like getting used to the cold happens when you move to Winnipeg (aka: Winterpeg). Despite our newfound comfort with the topic, I don't seek out poop-related experiences. I guess they just find me.

I took both Saturday and Sunday to stay home this weekend and not do work. It was great to have two consecutive days off and to do family activities. Sunday was snowy here and a perfect day to hang out in the house, play with the wee one and watch some football, which was conveniently on. With the Wee one asleep, I settled into the couch with beer in hand, ready for some mindless entertainment. From behind me I heard our cat scrambling up the basement (where we keep the litter boxes) stairs at breakneck speed until he hit the kitchen laminate floor and lost all traction despite churning his legs at a blurring pace. I couldn't figure out what had spooked him until he bolted into the living room and I could see that he had a ball of poop whipping around behind him like a tether ball in a hurricane and attached by a strand of hair to apparently yet-to-be-excreted poop. Upon reaching the living room floor he instantly pushed his ass to the floor, legs splayed, and performed the front-legged ass-drag, commonly associated with dogs. He made it about 5 feet before I could reach him and pin him down long enough to pull a paper towel out of my pocket (I am now often armed with a cleaning device of some kind), grab the poop-caboose and pull on it like turning on a lamp. Luckily the hair snapped rather than pull the internal turd free from the cat and I was able to set the beast free while I disposed of the shit-on-a-rope and got some soap to clean the violated stretch of floor.

Ah, the joys of relaxing at home.

Friday, January 16, 2009

Humor me, politically

I try to avoid politics here because there are plenty of sources out there for political views. But allow me an indulgence, because it bears on what many of the female bloggers in this realm are often faced with. We'll get there in a sec.

Last night I was curious to see how the US president over the last 8 years was going to sum up his terms in office. How would he put a positive spin on 8 years that have been characterized by bad decisions, lack of accountability and deep divisions within the country? I put up with that smarmy smirk for 15 minutes (a personal best) to find out. The answer was trusty old 9/11. The best thing Bush could come up with was "sure, thousands and thousands of civilian lives have been taken since 9/11, but none of them were American!" Well, I feel better.

But what really struck me about the farewell I've been waiting 8 years for was the middle of the speech, when Bush highlighted his “random honorable people of note”. Other than the fallen 9/11 officer who Bush mentioned, four people had been invited to the speech for Bush to pat them on the back for honorable service to the country. There was a charter school principal, the religious owner of a half-way house, a military hero, and the father of a fallen soldier who had petitioned the armed serviced to be allowed to join the army at the age of 64 in order to be a battle medic and up-hold the memory of his son. Fair enough, I can hardly argue whether or not these individuals are worthy of Presidential praise. But the thing that stood out was the fact that not a single woman made the list of presidential honorees. Not one of four.

As a confession, I will readily admit that I might not have thought this was a big deal not so long ago. Is this outward sexism as featured in an after-school special? No. But it may be every bit as important because these types of “oversights” subtly reinforce the idea that men should be recognized for achievements, whereas woman should operate in the background. I have heard (read) similar types of complaints regarding scientific awards, teaching awards and seminar invites in the last couple of months and it all adds up over time. Who are the role models being paraded before us? Who are the people winning the awards? Can anyone really argue that the four men Bush chose to invite to his final speech as President better represent the good in our country than any women candidates out there? My only explanation other than Republican arrogance is that many women were invited, but none wanted to be associated with Bush. Now there’s an honorable stance.

Thursday, January 15, 2009

I swear, I'm gonna face it

Between grants, preparing to move the lab* and having a new student start it has been very easy to ignore the elephant in the room. Now that I have weekend plans (including a date night with my wife, who has been very tolerant of my long hours) and only a few days before classes start up again, the elephant is starting to get gassy and is becoming impossible to ignore. In my case, that elephant is the course I have to teach this semester.

As courses go, it should be incredibly straight-forward. It's a grad class with only about 6 students and it's on a topic that I find fascinating. I think this class is going to be something I really enjoy doing, but for an unknown reason I am completely paralyzed when it comes to planning for the class, now that it is right around the corner. I have a general idea of how I want to teach it, but I can't bring myself to lay out the schedule or deal with the syllabus. There is no real reason of my complete avoidance, but it is a bit daunting to have an entire course to plan from scratch. Like most people in my position, I don't have any formal teacher training and have never had to plan a course. Since I have been here I have only concentrated on research, which is entirely familiar and not the least bit scary. It's what gets me up in the morning (well, technically I get up to the screaming of our hungry alarm clock that needs a new diaper) and why I put in long hours. Teaching is the thing I always knew I would have to do, but haven't looked forward to. I am confident I will enjoy teaching, but for now it represents the great unknown. Today, however, I brought my elephant gun and it's huntin' time... after lunch.


*I got to go over to the new building again today and tour my new space. I didn't want to leave. Like yearning for a distant lover, it's constantly in my thoughts. I can't wait until I can see it again, move in with it and start a new life together. Alright, maybe that's creepy, but the space rocks.

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Officer, what seems to be the problem?

For various reasons, I'm relatively new to applying for NSF grants. One thing that I have been told from a number of people was to write to my potential program officers and ensure that the proposal I am submitting fits their program. I did not do this with the grant I submitted before moving from Postdoc City and it ended up getting bounced to a different program from the one I had sent it to. In this funding round the second grant I am submitting (with Senior Collaborator) doesn't fit neatly into any of the program descriptions, so I figured it was time to get in touch with some of the POs and figure out the best home for it.

I contacted two POs from different divisions under BIO. The first got back to me with interest and the second wrote back with questions that suggested that they had not really read what I had written. I sent an email back to both, taking time to carefully explain the project in greater detail to PO2. PO1 got back to me and said that our proposal could likely fit under their program, but that I should also look into the program of PO2. I never heard from PO2. Three weeks go by and with the deadline less than two weeks away, I recontacted PO2 about the proposal. After a couple of days I got a response, suggesting that I should send it to their program and how PO2 appreciated me doing my homework ahead of time. Fair enough.

Then we ran into some problems and SC decided that the program deadline just wasn't going to happen. I wanted to let PO2 know that we might be a couple of days late so that I might get some assurances that they would still take the proposal, so I wrote 3 days before the deadline. Nothing. The day of the deadline, I wrote again. Nothing. Now we're two days past and I still haven't heard anything. It may all be moot because SC called me last night to let me know that it might be better to hold off until March for a different program and after seeing the draft of the proposal for the first time last night, I can see why SC feels this way. Can I get a "This is why I wanted to spread the writing between us!" from the congregation?

But I'm left with two issues. 1) I know that POs are busy and have a lot going on, but PO2 is one of 4 POs for this particular program, which receives fewer than 75 proposals according to NSF stats. Is it unreasonable to expect that a PO will get back to you in a timely manner, particular about specific requests having to do with the deadline? A simple "we won't take proposals after xx date" would be fine, but no answer is a bit shitty. 2) Now that SC has run up the white flag on this round, do I bother to contact PO2 and say "Uh, we're more incompetent than even we thought, so you don't have to worry about our late proposal anymore."? I probably should out of courtesy because I may send something to this program in the future, but if PO2 is too busy or doesn't care enough to get back to me, it's possible yet another email will just elicit an exasperated sigh.

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Faculty Fiasco

What is it about academics that so many of us feel the need to wax poetic about the problems associated with any process that is bringing about change? Our college is in the process of dramatically re-organizing it's structure at all levels. These changes will be harder for some of the small departments than the large ones, but the Dean has suggested a plan, which is being tinkered with by a committee of the department chairs with feedback from their departments. No one is being left out of the process and there have been many opportunities to weigh in.

One of those opportunities was yesterday, in a full meeting of the college faculty. The chairs and the dean presided over the meeting and discussion. Because there has been so much turmoil over the different re-organization models, the meeting started off with a very simple premise. A motion was introduced that essentially stated that the faculty would empower the committee of Chairs to create a small number of sub-committees, each of which will have the task of investigating a specific aspect of the re-organization (eg. Graduate education, undergraduate education, administration of the new organizational bodies, etc.). So, already we have a committee of departmental representatives begetting a new generation of committees. Great.

But here's the kicker. We don't even have a proposed structure of the college that anyone can agree on yet! Several have been proposed, but people felt that it was impossible to evaluate them without filling in the details of the models. But how are we supposed to fill in details when we don't have a defined structure? Are we supposed to waste time filling in the details of five different models? The whole thing is a giant steaming turd as far as I'm concerned, and all people wanted to do was complain about change rather than doing anything. We spent an hour and a half letting people vent about why and how they were opposed to the idea of change. One guy even started out with "I feel adrift, with no idea where I'm floating and no land in sight." This prompted me to turn to my neighbor and friend to say "I had no idea the drama department was in our college!" Maybe having two junior faculty trying not to make it obvious that they were mocking others in the college was not the best idea, but for fuck's sake.

I don't envy the dean. He is trying hard to have the final plan come from the ground up rather than forcing us into a scheme. I think that is a good idea, but it's like herding cats. Trying to get almost 100 faculty members to agree on anything is a monumental challenge, but on a completely new organization for the entire college? Epic.



Figure 1. The Dean's new job.

Monday, January 12, 2009

A big day

There's a lot going on today in the land of PLS. The first and most obvious is that it's grant due day. My solo grant is ready to go after one last once-over. I didn't get all the data I wanted to put in, but I think I got enough. Combined with strengthening the methodology and the Broader Impacts section, I'm pretty happy with it. My only fear is the dreaded "too ambitious" tag. Obviously I don't think it is too ambitious, but it could be read that way by someone who doesn't do the type of stuff we do. I guess I will have to wait.

Grant #2 is an unknown. Still no draft from Senior Collaborator after promises to have it to me on Friday. Still nothing back from the program officer to allay me fears that it is going in late and that she won't accept it. Nevertheless, my part is done (without being able to comment on the proposal) and I will have my grants people sign off on it today.

I also have a New Grad Student starting today. I don't know that NGS will get the chance to do much today but figure things out around the dept./university, but it'll be good to have another person in the lab.

Finally, as though this wasn't enough, the college is having an all faculty meeting today to battle it out of the new structure going forward. I'm not sure if it's going to be a giant cage match or a civil presentation, but it could be anything along that spectrum. Will there be blood? I don't know, but I think I'm hiding a smock under me seat in case it gets as messy as the front row at The Blue Man Group.

UPDATE: Grant #1 submitted. Still no draft from SC and no answering their phone either. College-level faculty meeting = epic fail.

Friday, January 9, 2009

Mandated Post-doc Mentoring

For anyone who is not writing an NSF grant for this round, you might be surprised to note that, as of January 5th, there are new rules regarding post-docs. The text reads as follows:

One of the most significant changes to the PAPPG is implementation of the mentoring provisions of the America COMPETES Act. Each proposal that requests funding to support postdoctoral researchers must include, as a separate section within the 15-page project description, a description of the mentoring activities that will be provided for such individuals. Proposals that do not include a separate section on mentoring activities within the Project Description will be returned without review.

I am all for the proper mentoring of post-docs, but this seems to me like just another thing to put words around in a grant. It's not going to change how I run the lab or how I plan to metor my post-docs. Is this just in here for old-timers who ignore post-docs?

It's actually a challenging little piece to write because my first version came across as though I was heaping a ton of responsibility for the lab onto the post-docs and sitting in my office with my feet up. Now I'm strugling with making it sound like a mentoring relationship without sounding like I'm going to be stalking my post-docs and smothering them. Ugh.

The Kübler-Ross grief grant cycle

I have a confession to make. I actually kinda like writing grants.

Before you immediately think "Dude, you should seek treatment", let me explain. I don't like the deadlines, the number of grants we have to write (each with their own format) or moving target of satisfying the panel. I do, however, like taking an idea and "selling" it in a way that makes someone who has never thought about what you are doing say "I want to see how this ends up." I think it's what we all like about what we do - the ability to excite people about our ideas and projects. If you can't explain what you are doing to someone and get them excited or interested, you're in the wrong business. Seriously, you're wasting your time.

Grants are the written embodiment of this pursuit. When you are writing a manuscript you have the results and you are reporting what you find in the best way you can. With a grant, you are selling the potential of something, which requires you to convince others of your ideas in the relative absence of data (even though you now have to have half a project done in order to get it funded, but that's a topic for another day). It requires a different way of writing and it's something I take a bit of perverse pleasure in.

That's not to say that the process isn't arduous. It is. But I have come to see it in terms of the The Kübler-Ross steps of grief:

Shock: Holy shit, that deadline is coming up fast! Is it that time of year already?

Denial: I still have plenty of time though, I can get a few things done before I really get into the writing.

Anger: How did I let myself wait so long?

Bargaining: This is the part where you figure out how to structure the grant. Which part do I emphasize for this particular grant opportunity? How ambitious do I make it? What can I fit into the budget without looking greedy? What personnel do I need to complete the project?

Depression: There is a point when writing every grant (at least for me) where I lose the forest for the trees and it seems like the grant is a scattered mush of directionless words, associated only by being in the same document. I usually have to put the whole thing down for a couple of days and come back and read the whole through, from start to finish. Only then do I regain some perspective and start making the connections.

Testing: I try and send it out to a couple of colleagues who are in different sub-fields. If they get it and understand why the project is exciting I know I'm on the right track. If not, it tells me where I need to strength my description or make connections more obvious.

Acceptance: When everything falls into place and I can read it and feel like I got all my points across. The only left to do at this point is submit the thing and hope for a second stage of acceptance.

Tropophobia

I knew there would be a name for it, there is for every fear. Tropophobia: the fear of moving. I would impress you with the derivation of the word if I haven't spent so much time in grade school Latin class giggling at words that sounded dirty.

In any case, there is a lot of Tropophobia going on around the building these days. As I mentioned earlier, I'm ready to walk out the front door of this building and toss a grenade over my shoulder, but others don't feel that way. I can understand that moving after being in the same place for 20+ years would be intimidating. Some of the labs around here are crammed full of shit from the Nixon era and I can hardly imagine what will be unearthed when we really do make the move. To me, the move would be a great opportunity for a fresh start, unencumbered by years of built up garbage equipment. But what the hell do I know? Many of the older faculty are looking at the move like it is going to cause an enormous loss of productivity while the lab packs and unpacks, but those who are complaining about this most vocally have time to do so, because they haven't published in ten years and I'm not sure what productivity they are worrying about.

What has not helped is the fact that we don't know when we will actually be moving, but we know it will be "soon". Basically, as soon as we CAN move in, they will want us out of here running, but no one knows when that will be. Rumors swirl around and we get updates like the Bush administration used to update the Terror Alert, post 9-11. I think the current move alert status in yellow, but it could go orange next week.

Thursday, January 8, 2009

Good grant/Bad grant

Monday is the target date for these two grants and it can't come soon enough. I will be very excited to have these done and out of my life for now.

Grant #1 is my baby and the main project I want to pursue in my lab. I'm really excited to pursue the questions in this grant and it will be the first step of my lab's long term goals. I am the sole PI on the grant and it is getting to my favorite stage of grant writing, where everything is coming together - the budget is all set, the text is in decent shape, with only a few little sections to fill out, and the higher-ups have mostly signed off on it, meaning I won't have to run around on Monday tackling people in the halls for their signature. It's organized, together and I won't be stressing about it in the final minutes.

Grant #2 is a totally different story. #2 is a collaborative project with a Senior Colleague. It's also a really exciting project and will lead to some kick-ass data at the end of the day. The physical grant, however, is a bit of a mess. SC has been doing most of the writing, but I still have yet to see even a decent draft. The budget is a skeleton and we are scrambling to get our broader impacts section project set up. To top it off, SC isn't exactly reading all my emails very well.

Actual conversation yesterday
PLS - I have a meeting with my grant people tomorrow, so if I could get the budget on your end and a draft I can have them sign off on it here.
SC - I'll see what I can do, but I hadn't planed on meeting with the people here until Tuesday.
PLS - Um, you do realize that the deadline is the 12th, right?
SC - I thought you told me the 15th.
PLS - It was the 9th, until I decided to send it to a different program after talking with the Program Officer.
SC - Not the 15th?
PLS - No, never the 15th.
SC - Hmmm, I'm not sure I can catch everyone here to get it signed off by the end of Monday.
PLS - (Long pause)
SC - Let me see what I can do, but can you talk to the PO and find out how "hard" the deadline is?
PLS - Suuuure, no problem. (thinking - Great, I get to go to the PO and tell her we're incompetent. Excellent.)
SC - Alright, talk to you tomorrow. Oh, I'm busy until 2:00.
PLS - Right then.

Thank goodness the NSF dates are "target dates" with a little flexibility, but for eff's sake.

No animals were injured in the making of this reinactment.

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Budgetary Bulimia

Why is it that every time I finish putting my budget together I look at the final number and feel sick. I'm going to ask them for how much? Where's the nearest bathroom?

Should I worry?

When I took this job there were three features that made it very attractive. 1) Location. Both my and my wife's families are within a 2 hour drive from where we live. After spending nearly a decade in a distant place and with a child under a year old, it was very appealing to finally be near family again. 2) Collaborations. The university is investing heavily in my subfield and has made several hires in that area recently, with another planned (assuming they lift the hiring freeze one day). 3) Work/Life balance. Though Employment U is not a superpower R1 research juggernaut, research is a major focus and well supported. Our class load is not overwhelming 1:1.5 (with the .5 being a journal club-type "class") and the deans are generous about accommodating active research. At the same time, one could putter along with a small research group and limited funding and still get tenure.

I have no plans to putter, but unlike Isis, I am too tall to sleep on my desk. I aim to build a decent sized lab (not a small corporation) and juggle between 2 and 4 grants at any one time. That's what I think it will take for me to feel happy with the progress my group is making and still be able to spend time with my family. There are people in the department who pull this off, but they are the minority.

Obviously, I have been pushing hard in the last month with the two grants I am about to submit, but I would say that I am generally here longer hours than most (maybe all) of the other PIs. I have been told several times in the last couple of weeks something to the effect of "people here just don't work as hard as you are", and if my experiences being the only person in the building over the holiday are any indication, they're right. This situation might change entirely when I move to the new building, in which only active labs are going, but maybe not.

Now, I may not get any of the grants I have submitted and might find myself nursing a single grant along for several years, I have no idea. I don't think that will be the case, but at this early stage I can only speak to my ambitions and nothing more. Nevertheless, am I going to be motivated to churn out grant proposals at this rate in five years if I am one of a few who are pushing that hard? The culture of your environment can have conscience and sub-conscience effects that influence your actions. I am (perhaps naively) relying on my internal drive and the pace of others in my field to keep me motivated to keep running, but will that be enough to keep from starting to jog?

Of course, the running metaphors are also serving to remind me that even jogging would be an improvement to sitting behind my desk or standing in the lab all day. Must. Get. Exercise. Fat ass.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Granting conundrum

In the midst of writing the grants I have been furiously working on, I have been approached about another opportunity by someone who was a post-doc in the lab I did my PhD. The grant combines part of the focus of my current lab with some of the work I did as a PhD student, so it is well within my wheelhouse. The problem is that I have an exceedingly low opinion of Former Post-Doc and don't trust FPD to tie their shoes, let alone write a million dollar grant that is fundable. But, before I dismissed the opportunity outright, I got some details and it turns out the FPD has recruited a Major Player in the field to be another co-PI.

So, the situation has changed, at least on the surface. MP would not likely get involved with something that stands no chance of being funded and MP is young enough where they are not just lending their name to the grant, but they would be involved in the writing and data analysis. MP also has the downstream resources to make this all work, whereas FPD most certainly does not and I am not ready to commit the resources required to a side project. With MP on board, there is a serious chance this could all work.

Normally I would throw my hat in the ring, but I can't escape the memories of FPD's incompetence in all things research related, and particularly in matters of data organization, which this project would require a lot of. After thinking about it, I see three possible outcomes if the project gets funded.

1) FPD makes my life hell with constant bungling of data and resources to the point where the student I would have dedicated to the project would be in a state of constant frustration and not get the most out of their degree.

2) MP exerts enough influence to keep FPD's insanity to tolerable levels and the project moves forward without too much trouble.

3) I carve out part of the project to focus on and exist on that island, while contributing to the whole in a minor way.

I could deal with either #2 or #3, but I would feel very good about option 3. No one wants to work with someone who flies with their parachute packed and one eye on the door, ready to jump at the first sign of trouble. That's also not how I like to operate. At the same time, if I get involved I absolutely have to safe-guard my interests from the natural disaster that is FPD.

Perhaps if I insist on a clearly defined list of responsibilities well before any writing gets done, I can adequately assess FPD's potential to sink the ship. I am loathe to get involved with a potential crippling collaboration so early on, but the possible data have me weighing the pros and cons.

Monday, January 5, 2009

Technically, you're an ass.

I understand that technicians are often under-appreciated for the work they do and that they regularly have to field demanding requests from lots of people. I also get that some of those requests might be beyond the scope of their job and that this can lead to a somewhat jaded and protectionist persona, but I don't think these factors excuse someone from being a miserable human being.

This morning I contacted the facility whose ultracentrifuge I used over the weekend to tell them about the drive malfunction and find out if they had experienced the problem before. They had not, but the junior technician in the lab asserted that the reason for the malfunction was because I had selected the "hold" option, rather than program in a time. I've worked with these centrifuges for 5 years and know that his argument holds no water. When I told him that I had never run into that problem, he became more defensive and confident in his diagnosis, which I just let slide (even after he admitted that his boss had much more experience with the machine - the same boss who set the run up with me) because maybe their particular machine is quirky. Plus, I was only looking to tell them in case the machine needs service, I was not suggesting that the failure of the run was anyone's fault.

After that "discussion" stalled out, I inquired whether he could suggest another lab that might have the tube caps, which would prevent my tubes from collapsing again. I prefaced this with the fact that I would be ordering my own set for the future, but that borrowing a set in the interim would be helpful so that I could complete my experiment. The response I got shocked me so much I didn't know what to say. "Well, that's really your problem and not something you should depend on us for." My simple request for the names of people to contact was really too much heavy lifting for him? He eventually suggested two labs who use the rotor frequently, but WTF? So, Junior Technician in Core Facility Across Campus, I raise a glass of F.U. in your general direction and hope that you don't live your life like you work your job.

That experience, combine with me going tits-up in the icy parking lot and landing on my computer bag, not two steps after leaving my car this morning, has made for an enjoyable day. Now I get to go home for dinner and bed time for the wee one before coming back and watching more experiments go as well as the Titanic's maiden voyage. Next Tuesday can't come soon enough.

Novelty in Science

Last week, Comrade PhysioProf asked how people go about generating novel scientific concepts in their field. I've been bogged down in the lab and didn't get a chance to sit down to respond until now. Most people responded suggesting that they either apply new methodology to an old problem or follow up on the most unusual or demanding data. While I think that is a key element, I would like to introduce another possibility: capitalizing on the diversity of nature.

I don't work on model organisms. In fact, one might argue that I do the exact opposite. My work thrives on finding the odd balls and misfits and trying to understand why they are the way they are and how they got to be that way. I don't mean chasing down spiny echidnas or duck-billed platipi, more like collecting and working with groups of organisms that you likely don't even know exist. It can be a painful way to proceed when so many major techniques can only be used when you have a basic knowledge of the organism. When you are starting from square one with a bug (generically speaking, not an insect) that has never been described before, or from which only basic descriptive details are known, there is a steep hill to climb before there is a big pay off.

Of course the flip side of that is the possibility (probability) that you stumble across something totally novel. As an example, take the case of the malaria pathogen, Plasmodium. The actual pathogen has been know for a long time and, as one might expect, been the subject of intense research since it was first isolated. TEM studies had shown an unusual organelle in Plasmodium of unknown function, which was termed the apicoplast (because this organelle is shared in other members of Apicomplexa, such as Toxoplasma, as well). It was unclear what the organelle did, but people hypothesized that it was involved in infection.

Combining established methodology and contemporary evolutionary hypotheses regarding the evolution of the group that includes apicomplexans, an international group showed conclusively (McFadden et al. 1996. Nature 381:482 - no link because of age of the paper) that the apicoplast is a relic plastid (chloroplast). Not only did this indicate that the apicomplexans evolved from photosynthetic algae into some of the nastiest pathogenic bugs out there, but it also provided a novel way to attack malaria without human side effects. If you can target drugs to plastid genes, there is no concern that human genes will get caught in the crossfire.

Now, if you have traveled to a country where malaria is a problem and taken the drugs, you are probably thinking "Bullshit, I took Chloroquine and there were certainly side-effects." That's true, mainly because of the difficulty in specific drug targeting into the apicoplast, but this avenue remains one of the most promising opportunities to prevent and even eliminate malaria at some point in the future.

So, novelty in science, for me, comes from exploring the strange and unusual things that have evolved all around us. There is no shortage, I can assure you, and there are probably fewer people studing 90% of eukaryotic diversity than there are studying a single human cell line. In fact, of this I am sure. If what got you into biology was not how blood flows through the body or that you wanted to hug dolphins one day, it's time to realize that animals are boring and plants are just dry algae. Get into to the literature a bit and see what else is out there.

Sunday, January 4, 2009

What's the worst that can happen?

Was what I was thinking when I left the lab across campus after starting the centrifuge. I had gone to a facility to use their ultracentrifuge for a project I am working on and was shocked to find that they did not have the caps that sit on top of the plastic tubes and keep them from distorting. Who has this rotor without the caps? It didn't make any sense. On the other hand, people had been using it for months at even higher speeds than I was, so I figured the tubes wouldn't be too badly affected. If they were, other people wouldn't be using it, right?


Figure 1. The worst that could happen.

Well, as you can see, they must be using something else. It's a fuzzy picture, but let me fill in the details you may not be able to see. That's a tube that previously contained material that I do not have much of. In fact, that was about 3/4 of the sample that I had spent a week in North Carolina getting. The tube utterly collapsed and crushed most of the sample out, which apparently then evaporated, because there is no sign of it anymore. The sample is likely useless now, though there is a slim chance I can recover a bit.

Deadlines will make you do stupid things without thinking them through. Dude. Fuck. Sigh.

Thursday, January 1, 2009

Why I shouldn't be trusted...

At least with kid's toys.

For Christmas this year, my sister-in-law bought our daughter a toy that basically shoots small plastic balls into the air with random amounts of force and, to a lesser degree, direction. While I appreciate the gift, it might be a bit early for the wee one because the balls go everywhere and it would take her forever to go collect them all and put them back into the ball-firing-mechanism. Nevertheless, it did amaze her to watch her older cousins play with the new toy and the noise of the music and fan added to an already overwhelming day for her.



Figure 1. Random ball-firing mechanism that can assult your child. Notice the green ball about to attack. Subsequent pictures have been confiscated for evidence.


So, what happens when you leave Daddy to entertain the wee one for several hours? He finds ways to get the wee one involved with her new toys. Knowing that the wee one likes fans and air blowing in her face, I thought it might be fun for her if I tipped the toy over and just had it blow air at her. Solid plan, it seemed, because wee one though this was very funny, with her limited hair blowing in the breeze. That was of course, until the one fatal flaw in the plan was revealed when the ball chamber, thought to be empty of contents, was hiding one surprise. I watched a two inch plastic ball launch out of an item I was aim at my daughter's head and plunk her squarely in the face and the wee one's transition from laughing to crying was seamless. The good news was that I did this directly in front of my mother-in-law. Oh, wait, that's not good news.

The interesting thing is that up until recently, the wee one has had a goldfish memory and would have been playing with that same toy 10 minutes later. That stage has apparently passed, because anytime we turn it on now she looks terrified and tries to scootch up any part of the nearest adult. This might be a toy that goes away for a while and comes out in a couple of months for a retry.

This is the last non-science post for a while, I promise. Happy New Year.